Colonel T.N Dupuy and Martin Van Creveld on Wehrmacht

 Colonel T.N Dupuy in his book Genius for war did prove that one German soldier was equal to three US soldiers because the German organisation was better ! They had a healthy tradition of Auftragsatkiks and a more vibrant officer corps .

Martin Van Creveld a professor teaching at an Israeli university also reached the same conclusion as Dupuy when he wrote Fighting Power  !

In Crisis in Command two US officers Gabriel and Savage reached the conclusion that US Army was plagued by a serious disease of apple polishing , sycophancy and hole punching ! I dont think it has come out of it since Crisis in Command was written !

The authors thus agreed that the real fighting material in Vietnam were sidelined while the staff types who hole punched came up.

Certainly US Army today is far inferior to the US Army in Vietnam in intangible military virtues thanks to characters like Rumsfeld who were proponents of privatising defense !


Rather reliance on private contractors has severelt eroded the Clausewitzian military virtue of the US Army ! Thus we have a US Ambassador in Afghanistan who is a lobbyist for 27,000 over paid private American and British security guards ! The whole US Congress appears to have been bought by the private security companies !

One thing is clear ! The US Army needs some Christian values ! It lacks that burning ideological nationalism of theWehrmacht and the Red Army though !

An army will not fight if its political leadership is lobbying for the wall street or for KBR or Global Security !





Agha H Amin

THE GREATEST TANK KILLER IN HISTORY

BUT HE HAD A BEAUTIFUL WIFE TOO
Connecting history while staying above narrow ideological or ethnic divisions and assessing todays events

Agha H Amin

Citizen of wilderness and stateless man